DocArzt and Friends Logo

Marc Oromaner’s Lost In Myth: A Tale of Two Kates—Why You Can’t Escape Fate

By Marc Oromaner,

  Filed under: Lost In Myth
  Comments: 23

Have you ever met someone for the first time who seemed really familiar to you? Strangely, this person likely wound up being an important player in your life. This exact scenario happens to Jack in LA X when he recognizes Desmond on the plane. In What Kate Does, Kate’s parallel life is once again setting up the scene for her to have a connection with Claire and baby Aaron. What if the reason for this familiarity is because we are recognizing these people from our future, or from the story of our destiny?

In the February 4th “Official LOST Audio Podcast,” Damon Lindelof insists that the “flash-sideways” we’re seeing in Season 6 are in fact not alternate timelines. In other words, they do not have any lesser value than the other timeline and both are of equal importance. For this reason, I will refer to events of the flash-sideways as occurring in a parallel timeline. This does not necessarily mean that the events are happening along side each other. As I pointed out last week (in “What the LA X in ‘LA X’ Really Refers To”), it is entirely possible that this off-island timeline will occur after the island storyline ends and what we are seeing is the resolution of the characters in the show.

Of course, it’s also possible that the two timelines are occurring alongside each other. If this is the case, it is likely that these ripples in time will eventually merge once the flash-sideways events of 2004 catch up to 2007. This may cause a continual loop that leads to the Losties (and the world) being stuck in time (similar to the Star Trek TNG episode “Cause and Effect” written about in “’Follow the Leader’—Can Changing One Moment Change Everything?”).

Whether the flash-sideways is occurring alongside the other timeline or will occur afterwards, since time is an illusion anyway, the mythological message is similar. The island can represent a realm where you create the story of your destiny, after which, you’re born into a life where you get to experience it. So, whereas in most of my mythological interpretations of the show, I describe the island as a metaphor for our world on earth, in this case, I’m reversing it by saying that the island could also be seen as a metaphor for a heavenly realm where we write the story of our lives. That’s the beauty of mythology: its metaphors lend itself to many interpretations as millions of Lost fans can attest to.

Imagine if before we are born, our soul (energy, karma, light, essence, player of the video game of life, etc.), decides on the story it wants to experience in this lifetime. It chooses the people and events that will help it to grow past the issues it had experienced in its last lifetime.  So, the people who are the closest to you will likely challenge you with your biggest issues since these issues will take the longest to resolve.  That’s why, as they sing in the Broadway play Avenue Q, “The More You [Love] Someone the More They Drive You Crazy.” Your family, loved ones, and coworkers are put into your life to help you overcome your biggest issues.

Some faiths even claim that we continually get reincarnated with the same set of souls lifetime after lifetime. So your best friend now could’ve been your father or mother in a previous life. Your lover could’ve been a teacher or competitor. Your boss could’ve been an enemy on the battlefield. We keep coming back with these same souls to work out these issues, just as the Losties seem to be doing in their parallel timeline, and these connections and experiences have all been planned in our soul story from the start.

From a narrative perspective, this spiritual metaphor is easier to understand if the flash-sideways is happening after the events of 2007 because it’ll give us a sense of closure. Yes, Kate started out on the run in this new timeline, just as before, but in “What Kate Does,” we see her do something that goes against her nature. Instead of running away from a problem she has created, she endangers herself by trying to make it right. By coming back to help Claire and going with her to the hospital, she puts her own life at risk for someone else. That’s redemption. Getting into the cab that was occupied by Claire is, of course, no accident. It is fate pulling the strings to enable Kate to experience a test she was always meant to have.

Speaking of “pulling the strings,” Heroes fans may have recognized the cab driver from that scene as David H. Lawrence XVII who plays “Puppet Master” Eric Doyle on the series. Doyle is a villain who can control people’s actions, and he especially likes doing so to the cute blonde on the show, Claire (the cheerleader). Was this a purposeful hint from the Lost producers or one of those happy coincidences set up by the puppet masters of our universe? Either way, the message is once again that Lost is simply giving us hidden messages that reveal truths about our world.

If our life story really is all planned out before we come to this world, it really could explain some of the more bizarre mysteries we experience here. As stated above, when we recognize some of the key players from our destiny we can get a sense that we already know someone the moment we meet them.  This could also explain love at first sight—your soul is instantly recognizing someone from your future that you are destined to have a soulful connection with. The soul doesn’t experience time, it is eternal, so it can recognize another soul from a future time or a past life. It may also just resonate with meeting someone from your predetermined chosen path—someone who is meant to help you successfully navigate it.

Another weird phenomenon this may explain is déjà vu. What if the phenomenon happens when you experience an event that your soul had planned to experience—particularly, a key event that would be pivotal for your destiny? Remembering this event as it occurs brings about a sense of déjà vu. Using Lost as an analogy, perhaps Kate got déjà vu helping Claire with her pregnancy. And if she goes on to help deliver Aaron, the feeling may really resonate. On Lost, the reason is because she has already helped deliver Aaron on the island. In life, it’s a metaphor for an event that was destined to happen—a person’s soul created a scenario to help eliminate their own selfish behavior by one day unselfishly helping someone else. Once this event actually transpires, you get déjà vu. Judging by Jack’s expression after he stares out of the window of the plane in the parallel timeline, the show is acknowledging this phenomenon. And if Sawyer and Juliet eventually go Dutch over a cup of coffee in the parallel timeline, perhaps they will have the feeling too. At the very least, it might be love at first sight. (Sorry Skaters and Jaters.)

Being that we seem to live in a realm of freewill however, what happens when we don’t successfully make the decision that will lead to our redemption? What happens when a young pregnant woman gives up the baby she was meant to raise herself or a former torturer keeps following orders to kill other people? Well, in the case of Claire and Sayid, you become taken by the dark side; possessed by a desire to do for the self alone. You do not make the hard choices; you are controlled purely by life circumstances and react to them. In a word, you become a zombie. Damon and Carlton had jokingly threatened that Season 7 would be the zombie season, but it would seem that it may have been Season 6—despite Sayid’s denial at Hurley’s accusation (a little head nod to the fans).

Once you’ve been taken by the dark side, can you escape? Yes, but often it will require much harder sacrifices than what was originally required, if only because after sinking further down you have that much further to climb up.  Sometimes, you sink so low that the ultimate sacrifice is required, as Anakin Skywalker found out in Return of the Jedi. Most of the time though, the challenges, while difficult, are not overwhelming and the universe will continually offer you opportunities to take them on. But the harder you fight against these challenges, the more aggressively the universe will throw them back at you. In other words, what you resist, persists.

The whole zombie resolution opens up a lot of possibilities on Lost. Is the reason why Richard Alpert has never aged because he was a zombie all along? Are Claire, Yemi (Mr. Eko’s brother) and Christian Shephard also zombies? If so, why would zombie Christian go through the trouble of wading out to sea where Jack saw him standing in Season 1? Was it just for the creepiness factor? His body couldn’t have been there because the “Missing Pieces” episode (acknowledged as canon) showed him on the island already before Jack even woke up. And, more importantly perhaps, how did he appear to Jack off island in the hospital in Season 5? On the other hand, since the smoke monster can take the form of the unburied dead without the need to posses the body, has he just taken the form of Christian, Claire, and Yemi? Has he also taken the form of the people who were the Adam and Eve skeletons from Season 1? Is that who Charles Widmore and Eloise Hawking are? When we first saw Jacob’s enemy, aka, the man in black, was this his original appearance, or was he simply taking the form of a dead person too?

So far, Season 6 seems to be bringing up more questions than it’s answering. Every time it answers one, it gives us three more. Whether or not we ever get any satisfying answers to Lost, I think the show has been more than redeemed in the answers it has given us about life. Helping us to understand why we’re here is really the biggest question that the show is helping us to answer. Sure, most of the wisdom is only coming through on a subliminal level, but it is coming through. And, this wisdom is helping to make us stronger so that we will be able to better navigate the challenges in our own lives. This is why most fans feel that Lost is more than a show. It’s a guide to our own redemption.

Marc Oromaner
is a New York City writer whose book, The Myth of Lost offers a simple solution to Lost and uncovers its hidden insight into the mysteries of life. He can be contacted in the discussion section of The Myth of Lost Facebook page.

The Myth of Lost is available on Amazon and

From TVFrenzy: True Detective s2 E8: Omega Station (First Thoughts)

  • Argo

    “it is entirely possible that this off-island timeline will occur after the island storyline ends”

    No, it’s not. Not even remotely.

    • Absz009

      I agree.

      • Zonker

        Well, since the show has embraced physical time-travel, anything is possible, including the on-island 2007 storyline continuing to play out over the course of Season 6, only to time-travel back to 2004 in order to play out the flash-sideways storyline. I hope not though, because I think the series finale should be on-island, not back in the real world of 2004 with a sunken island left behind.

    • RodimusBen

      I really hope not. I want the end to be THE END, to give some finality to the series.

    • greg dharma

      actually, it’s been hinted at by claire’s sonogram, dated one month after the crash would have occurred. so that’s more than remotely possible, i’d say.

    • Handsome Smitty

      Yup, it is real and happening. Jughead worked, blew a hole in the Island or launched the spaceship, sinking the Island.

      Only problem is, the timeline is all jaggy. Some O6 are stuck in ’77 an others in ’07. Until that conundrum is resolved, what happened with Juggy cannot be fully realized.

      Will the stuck-out-of-gear O6 (only Jin – and maybe Aaron or the Jin/Sun baby!?!) somehow be needed back in ’77 to again pop that bomb!?!

      Ugh, my head is spinning – time to drive the porcelain bus!!!

  • Eric

    Argo, care to explain WHY it’s not remotely possible?

  • Ed Holden

    “And, more importantly perhaps, how did [Christian] appear to Jack off island in the hospital in Season 5?”

    I think that was in season 4. But good point. I’ve been wondering that as well.

    “When we first saw Jacob’s enemy, aka, the man in black, was this his original appearance, or was he simply taking the form of a dead person too?”

    My prediction is that we will see that actor again, but playing a different character – that is, the one Smokie was emulating when we saw him in the Season 5 finale.

  • naultz

    Great article Marc. Some times we, as viewers, get so caught up in the show’s questions that we forget to listen to the show’s message. And the way we can look into our own lives to find the same themes, great point. I’ve always wondered about these off-island appearances. Could it be that once you are on the island, a part of the island is with you always, able to manifest off island as well. Most of the characters( Ana Lucia, Charlie, Mr. Eko) seen off island were by Hurley, so maybe his ability to see and talk with the “dead” would explain these sightings, but jack seeing his father is still a mystery to me.

  • jojolost

    Great post Marc. I’m still trying to get a sense of this whole “zombie” thing. Your article helped. I remember Ethan way back in the jungle looking at Claire (not sure what episode) and thinking “why is he just standing there staring at Claire? Boy,he looks like a zombie”.

    Also, here’s a question maybe you can help answer regarding the MIB/Monster/Black Smoke. Didn’t Ben summon the black smoke to attack Keamy’s mercenaries in “The Shape of Things to Come”? I thought Ben was on Jacob’s side? Was the smoke monster not the MIB at that time? I’m confused about this. Can you help?

    • David

      Keamy’s mercenaries attacks and kills/infects Claire. Keamy kills Ben’s daughter allowing MiB to use that later to manipulate Ben. MiB/Smokey kills/drives off the mercenaries allowing Ben and Locke to escape and head to the cabin to get instructions from Christian/MiB (with Claire) to move the island furthering MiB’s plans to kill Jacob.

    • Handsome Smitty

      We don’t know the “infection” is MIB related or not. While Dogen mentioned a darkness, he was still vague.

      We also don’t know said infection is even real, or perhaps Dogen just doesn’t understand it.

    • Marc Oromaner

      Much like Senator Palpatine in “Star Wars: Attack of the Clones,” it seems as though MIB is playing both sides to suit his needs.

  • greg dharma

    marc, just wanted to say i really enjoy your thoughtful commentary. i like how you remind us that, while lost is just a TV show, it can show us something about life which will remain with us long after the series ends.

    you are on point with your musings about deja vu and redemption. but i think you go a bit overboard with the zombie train of thought. widmore and hawking as zombies claimed by MiB? c’mon. i dont think so.

    plus we dont actually get confirmation that anyone is a zombie, just that sayid has been claimed, which hints claire has been claimed too. the question becomes, then, did claire actually die? or was she just seduced/led to the dark side. we saw her get taken. we saw her in jacob’s cabin with christian shepard (MiB). now we see her stepping into Rosseau’s jungle boots. we havent seen her actually die, just a feral expression on her face.

    i dont think we’re gonna get answers to every single question.

    but as far as moving forward, so far Flocke is outnumbered by the Jacobians. He needs more followers. Claire could be acting alone, or on his side. Ben seems to be on his side, but we dont really know. and Richard? he’s currently imitating a burlap sack. at the least, flocke’s got to go on a recruitment drive to prevent Jacob’s resurrection/redemption so he can return home, wherever that is.

    • Handsome Smitty

      Why does MIB need anyone? Seems he can handle himself pretty well.

      Then of course, there are those “rule” (silly, perhaps) created by the writers, like MIB couldn’t kill Jacob himself. Somehow this rule applies to only certain people, and that certain person MIB now wants dead is Jack, achieved through his nemesis, Sawyer.

  • DanielleB

    Thanks for mentioning the puppet master – I was thinking the same! So many puppet masters Ben/Charles Widmore, Jacob/MIB, Damon/Carlton ….

  • Tommy Buchner

    Many thanks for taking this opportunity to discuss this, Personally i think strongly regarding it and I make use of learning about this subject. If possible, as you gain data, please update this site with new information. I have discovered it extremely useful.

  • Alfredo Ostler

    One thing is that often one of the most popular incentives for making use of your cards is a cash-back and also rebate supply. Generally, you’ll have access to 1-5% back in various expenses. Depending on the card, you may get 1% back again on most expenditures, and 5% again on expenditures made from convenience stores, gas stations, grocery stores plus ‘member merchants’.